--Doc , 3 July 2006 (UTC) 70 years ago, I would have definitely agreed with you, the actor would be very notable, and would deserve the main page.
Currently, both actors appeal to niche markets, which is why I think the default page should be the disambiguation page.
I bet you that the 2nd Erik Rhodes's movies generate more money than the 1st ones currently do.--Todd , 3 July 2006 (UTC) Pornography has always made money, but in this case you are evaluating an actor who's appeal is to a limited part of the gay community.
I had not heard of Ernest Sharpe before a couple of days ago, and I doubt very many people have.
However for the present, I have followed the solution that I have seen used before where there are many links for the most known name which is to redirect to that name and with pointers to the disambiguation page at the top of both pages.
This may end up the final solution, but we'll see what admin input we get.
What we really need here is the input of other neutral persons on the principal not the persons in question.
Doc , 3 July 2006 (UTC) I think we both agree that the porn star is part of a niche market, so I guess the issue is whether or not the actor is as well.